Mariah Carey Popular Song Rankings [2026]

Love StoryMariah Carey50rank/position

Mariah Carey – Love Story

This is a song included on Mariah Carey’s album E=MC².

The lyrics overflow with love, and Mariah’s passionate vocals match the slow-tempo sound beautifully.

If you play it at a wedding, it will likely bring back memories of the couple’s love story leading up to the ceremony and fill everyone with happiness.

It would also leave a beautiful afterglow if used as the closing song at the reception.

Love Takes TimeMariah Carey51rank/position

Mariah Carey – Love Takes Time (Official HD Video)

This is an R&B masterpiece by Mariah Carey, an artist whose outstanding pop sensibilities have earned her worldwide acclaim and who excels at crafting clubber-friendly tracks.

Its polished finish brings a vibrant flair that makes it perfect for summer.

Make It HappenMariah Carey52rank/position

Mariah Carey – Make It Happen (Official HD Video)

A gem of a ballad that delivers Mariah Carey’s own survival story, singing that even in difficult times dreams can be realized through prayer and effort.

Released in 1992 from the album Emotions, this song is her most personal message, written from real experiences of overcoming poverty and loneliness before her debut.

Its sound fuses the uplifting spirit of gospel—enhanced by church choir elements—with a dance beat, culminating after the bridge in a climax that evokes a prayer-like sense of awe.

It reached No.

5 on the U.S.

charts and became a long-running hit in April 1992.

It’s a song that gives you a push when you’re facing hardship or about to take a new step forward.

MiMariah Carey53rank/position

Mariah Carey – Mi (Official Lyric Video)

Included as the opening track on the September 2025 album “Here for It All,” this song bears a title featuring the Spanish word for “me,” and serves as a renewed declaration of self-affirmation and agency from Mariah Carey, 35 years after her debut.

With wry punchlines that assert her diva pride, and a sound that layers multi-part harmonies and deft ad-libs over a minimal trap beat, it vividly presents a 2025 vision of Mariah that generates power through space and hooks rather than relying on the flawless, old-school vocal perfection.

It’s a track befitting an artist who continues to steer her own career, distilling a contemporary message that makes her value and negotiating power unmistakably clear.

Miss You Most (At Christmas Time)Mariah Carey54rank/position

Mariah Carey – Miss You Most (At Christmas Time) (Official Video)

It’s a gentle ballad by Mariah Carey included on her album “Merry Christmas,” released for the holiday season in the ’90s.

Created in 1994 as a collaboration with Walter Afanasieff, the song expresses the loneliness and heartache of not having a loved one by your side during the festive Christmas season.

Its calm arrangement featuring strings and Carey’s emotive vocals really resonate.

It’s a piece that quietly touches the heart when listened to on a Christmas spent apart from a partner or on a night when memories of a past love resurface.

My AllMariah Carey55rank/position

Mariah Carey – My All (Official HD Video)

This Latin-tinged ballad, released as the final single from the 1998 album “Butterfly,” became her 13th No.

1 on the U.S.

charts.

Inspired by the culture she experienced in Puerto Rico, it sets a poignant longing for a separated lover against the sound of acoustic guitar.

From whispery lows to soaring highs in the finale, Mariah Carey’s delicate vocals shine throughout.

The monochrome music video directed by Herb Ritts is equally beautiful, with seaside and lighthouse imagery that enhances the song’s sensual world.

A heart-stirring classic ballad, perfect for nights when you can’t be with the one you love.

O Holy NightMariah Carey56rank/position

Mariah Carey – O Holy Night (Official Video)

It is a Christian hymn often sung at Christmas and during Mass, celebrating the birth of Christ.

Many singers have covered it, but this is the version covered by Mariah Carey, and she often performs it at her Christmas concerts.